By TODAYshow.com contributor and "Ask Kitty" columnist, Kitty Schindler
In a column last year, I wrote about growing up in a small town where children were everyone's concern. "Spare the rod and spoil the child" seemed to be universally accepted, which meant that friends, neighbors and relatives all could (and did) involve themselves how we kids behaved.
Today’s moms and dads are often better educated in parenting than mine were. Even so, many are uncertain about how to discipline their own children, much less the children of others. Do we live in such a “mind your own business” world that we are afraid to speak out when we see others’ children – or their parents -- misbehave?
Say you see a mother whose child is acting up in a store administer a slap on the bottom. That's fine with me, if it's moderate; if it's child abuse, it’s an entirely different situation. But let’s say the mother does nothing to correct a child who is obviously misbehaving: Should you intervene?
Unless someone is being endangered, probably not. Getting involved might only make the situation worse, for both child and mother. Still, if you see a small child trying to clamber out of a shopping cart while the mother isn't looking, there’s nothing wrong with telling the child, in a calm, friendly voice, to sit down -- or to alert the mother in the same modulated tone. Helping keep a child safe is always appropriate, regardless of whose it is. (And it's a lot better than helping to pick the child up off the floor.)
But when the child is older, our scenario becomes more complex. Some older children nowadays won't listen to their own parents, let alone you. And if an outsider intervenes, the parents often defend the bad behavior of the child. That’s what makes life so difficult for schoolteachers these days, and why discipline in schools is so often a problem.
Granted, there are many more influences on older children today than when I was growing up: TV, movies, rap music, social networking, texting and celebrity misbehavior, to name just a few. Bad examples can contribute to anti-social behavior. Bullying, taunting, teasing and the like are almost epidemic among older children, and have had tragic consequences.
But there are things a parent can do. When other children came to my home to play with my kids, they had to obey the rules of the house. It was my house, and if I was to be responsible for them, they had to follow my rules.
If someone didn't, he or she got one warning, and that usually was all it took. And when we got a swimming pool, there were even stricter rules. Anyone who disobeyed was sent home; no second chance.
I know that some of my children’s friends thought I was pretty strict when I took games away from them or even sent a couple home. But it was pretty easy to maintain order, because everyone knew my rules and for the most part didn't object.
My kids are all grown up now, but when my retired husband did some substitute teaching recently, he maintained classroom discipline in much the same way. Every student was told the rules every day, and the first to violate them was sent to the principal’s office. The others realized misbehavior wasn’t going to be tolerated, and for the rest of the day his classes were peaceful and productive. Children of almost any age will accept rules and discipline if those rules are enforced. If they aren’t, what good are they?
Today’s world is a lot different than the little town I grew up in, where everyone pretty much agreed on the ground rules. These days, if you’re not the one in charge – in your own home or classroom, for example – it’s wise to mind your own business unless a situation requires more.
But if it does, don’t be afraid to act accordingly. Times may have changed, but if I saw a child behaving recklessly, endangering himself or others, I would do whatever I thought necessary to eliminate the risk.
Video: Tips to dole out discipline to another parent's child
What do you think? Is it OK to discipline other people's children?