advertisement
TODAYMoms Home
  • TODAYMoms Home
  • TODAYMoms Blog
More tagged , , ,

Does race in movies and on TV matter to young kids?

There's been a lot of hype around Disney's debut of its first black princess in the movie "The Princess and the Frog." But some say that in the era of Sasha and Malia Obama, the historic nature of Tiana doesn't register with little kids. Do you think seeing characters like Tiana has an impact on children? Do your children see a diversity of characters on TV and in movies?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 8 short comments
Total of 339 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

31.9%
Yes
108 votes
56%
No
190 votes
12.1%
I'm not sure
41 votes
Display Comments:
No

I want my kids to understand that it does not matter what color the skin is it matters what the person is like once you get to know them.

{"commentId":10664586,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"jamib"}
     - jamib
     - 2:50 pm EST on Fri Nov 13, 2009
    No

    my nephew (white), when he was 5 or 6, was surprised to learn one of his uncles was black & he saw him frequently

    {"commentId":10665377,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"jmc525"}
       - 3:21 pm EST on Fri Nov 13, 2009
      No

      I don't care what the "studies" say: young children are color blind.

      {"commentId":10684909,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"tpuntoni"}
      • 2 votes
       - 12:24 am EST on Sun Nov 15, 2009
      No

      Now we as grownups need to drop the race card and just be people, friends, neighbors, cohumans. Take a lesson from the kids.

      {"commentId":10691636,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"millettkim"}
      • 2 votes
       - 4:08 pm EST on Sun Nov 15, 2009
      No

      They don 't see color the way we adults do...Thank God the world is changing.

      {"commentId":10695124,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"marcella-2"}
      • 1 vote
       - 10:13 pm EST on Sun Nov 15, 2009
      I'm not sure

      the is no issue with the race of the haracter aslong as it follows the story line, like cinderella is from europe, Mulan is asian etc.

      {"commentId":10695492,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"lorraine-forston"}
         - lore3
         - 10:56 pm EST on Sun Nov 15, 2009
        No

        How can prejudice die when we keep posting flags and news articles about "Lookey here!! First colored (insert character, positiion, etc.)!!

        {"commentId":10742998,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"sugar-cane"}
        • 1 vote
         - 2:55 am EST on Wed Nov 18, 2009
        No

        If we're teaching them how important race is, then we're just setting things up for trouble. just let them be colorblind.

        {"commentId":10815854,"threadId":"723646","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"megfzn18"}
           - 11:20 am EST on Sat Nov 21, 2009

          Newsvine Discussion with 6 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.

          {"commentId":10658932,"authorDomain":"jenninstlu"}

          I think it's important for them to see diversity on t.v. and movies because kids do see differences in skin color. When my son was three he would say things like, "There is a little brown boy." We shouldn't ignore skin color, we should talk about it and make sure they understand that everyone's the same on the inside. There are still so many prejudiced adults out there who make ignorant comments and kids do pick up on what they hear and see. We need to start talking about race at a young age and continue reinforcing commonalities as they grow older.

          {"commentId":10658932,"threadId":"723603","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"jenninstlu"}
            Reply#1 - Fri Nov 13, 2009 11:56 AM EST
            {"commentId":10680553,"authorDomain":"jenninstlu"}

            I'm white and live in a mostly white area and I do think it matters. If kids don't see people of other races and religions on t.v. and in the movies, especially if they live in a mostly white area, they could develop sterotypes that are perpetuated by many people in our society. I'm curious to know what people who are other races feel about this.

            {"commentId":10680553,"threadId":"723603","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"jenninstlu"}
            • 1 vote
            Reply#2 - Sat Nov 14, 2009 4:23 PM EST
            {"commentId":10691667,"authorDomain":"millettkim"}

            If what's important is the inside why do we spend so much time talking about the outside? As long as we're still arguing about our outsides and who gets the most coverage etc. then we're on the wrong track. We haven't truly succeeded until we stop seeing what's on the outside. We see a nice person or a mean person, or a successful person or a poor person but not black vs. white vs. oriental, etc.

            {"commentId":10691667,"threadId":"723603","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"millettkim"}
              Reply#3 - Sun Nov 15, 2009 4:12 PM EST
              {"commentId":10705307,"authorDomain":"ennidduffey"}

              kids don't care about color of skin. They olny care about how everyone is treated. They don't discover skin color until 8 or 9 or someone points it out. I wish everyone was like my 6 year old granddaughter.

              {"commentId":10705307,"threadId":"723603","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"ennidduffey"}
                Reply#4 - Mon Nov 16, 2009 2:59 PM EST
                {"commentId":10713741,"authorDomain":"angela-1471535"}

                We are the ones who are teaching our children that there is a difference between the races, or that there even are other races. We need to leave them alone in that area and just do what comes naturally. You can always tell which kids have been "poisoned" by their parents by looking at a playground. Most kids will happily play with any kid no matter what the race and gender and that's an absolutely beautiful thing. Children, unless an adult or several adults have gotten to them, are born color blind and we need to do what we can to make sure it stays that way! In fact, a lot of adults could learn from children in this and many other areas of life!

                {"commentId":10713741,"threadId":"723603","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"angela-1471535"}
                  Reply#5 - Mon Nov 16, 2009 9:26 PM EST
                  {"commentId":11127997,"authorDomain":"LOVE1"}

                  Does race in movies and on TV matter to young kids?

                  All children should be given the opportunity to identify with images that they are familiar with! Many people of different ethnicities are not given that opportunity in a variety of spectrums within the media. Often when children can not identify with the images provided they tend to develop a poor perception of how the world perceives and values them. The extreme affect would be child developing a decrease; in self love, acceptance of themselves and members of their same ethnicity/race. As adults we often inquire and address our children's issues from the perspective of how we think our children would react, instead of internalizing and taking on the feeling, thoughts and perspectives of a child (which is a blank slate until educated and influenced by their home, school and community). Does race matter in movies and on TV to young kids? Its argue-able, but I truly believe that children just want to be loved, accepted and able to identify with "something" that reflects themselves (even the big kids aka adults). However it is our job as adults to make sure those images are provided for them.

                  In 1997, while volunteering after school at a local Nashville Daycare, Ebonierose Wade saw the need for African American children's entertainment characters. At age fifteen, Ebonierose Wade founded and created Rosa's Doll House, a Children's Entertainment Company that now functions successfully throughout; Tennessee, South Louisiana, New York, North Virginia, Maryland and Washington, DC.

                  ROSA'S DOLL HOUSE IS A PREMIER CHILDREN'S PARTY ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY.

                  SINCE 1998, ROSA'S DOLL HOUSE HAS PROVIDED INCREDIBLE COSTUME CHARACTERS, BEAUTIFUL PRINCESSES, CLOWNS, SUPER HEROES AND MANY PARTY CHARACTERS TO MAKE YOUR CHILDS SPECIAL DAY A LASTING MEMORY!


                  www.rosadollhouse.com

                  {"commentId":11127997,"threadId":"723603","contentId":"3497802","authorDomain":"LOVE1"}
                    Reply#6 - Thu Dec 10, 2009 4:29 AM EST
                    {"canLink":false,"threadId":"723603","isPrivate":false}
                    Leave a Comment:
                    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.