TODAY Moms

sponsored by
advertisement
More tagged ,

Should she have let her son meet his dying dad?

A single mom was faced with a dilemma: Should she let her 2-year-old son see his terminally ill father and risk her son coming to love him, only to lose him again? Read the full story and share your thoughts.

advertisement
advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 275 short comments
Total of 8,649 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

92.5%
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.
7,998 votes
7.5%
No. It was a selfish request on the father's part. Why didn't he care to be part of his son's life before he got sick?
651 votes
Display Comments:
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

I know that you think about how awful he is but what would God do, so yes she did the right thing.

  • 1 vote
 - 9:01 am EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

She did the right thing, allowing a dying parent his final wish and allowing her sweet son to create memories of his dad.

  • 2 votes
 - 10:39 am EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

I lost my dad at 48 to cancer, you did the right thing. It was not your decision, it was your son's, you made the right choice for him

  • 1 vote
 - 11:09 am EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

Not allowing dad to connect with his son would have been something she would have had to live with and answer to later by her son.

  • 3 votes
 - 11:11 am EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

yes, she did the right thing for her son. he should be allowed a loving memory of his father, and closure of his father's absence.

  • 2 votes
 - 11:14 am EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

She fulfilled a wish that he was able to take to the grave with him. She was very mature about the situation. Keep his memory alive for him

  • 2 votes
 - 11:58 am EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

Through a child, God works so many miracles.

     - 12:02 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
    Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

    Death is a part of life. I feel that Judah would have been angry as an adult knowing his mother kept him away. Right Decision. Forgiving.

    • 2 votes
     - 12:05 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
    Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

    ...it ended up being his dying wish, and everyone involved 'grew' in their relationships with each other and the realities of the world.

    • 3 votes
     - 12:06 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
    Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

    It's rare (and sad) today that someone considers someone else's feelings over their own. Absolutely the right thing.

    • 2 votes
     - 12:07 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
    Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

    Dad planned on a relationship when the boy got older. Kids need mom the most untill they are around 10.

       - 12:13 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      Most assuredly yes! I never knew my father and would give anything to even have faint memories or pictures.

      • 2 votes
       - 12:18 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      Great choice, u have the picures and the brief memories. Whats best for "us" adults is not allways whats best for a child!

      • 1 vote
       - 12:22 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      I feel its better that he knew his father loved him rather than feeling abandoned later in life. As some kids with single mothers do.

      • 3 votes
       - 12:24 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      (SOBB) Yes, she did the right thing! I honestly feel that had she not allowed them to bond he would have hatred toward his mother later.

      • 1 vote
       - 12:25 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      I think she did the right thing. Children are stronger than we think and often can rationalize better than we give them credit for.

      • 1 vote
       - 12:26 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      Love is always best. Loss can be terrible, but it's part of life! He'll face it eventually, so why not let him know the love of a dad now?

      • 2 votes
       - Cyndi-B
       - 12:28 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      when her son gets older, he will remember more than she realizes as long as she helps keep the fathers memory alive.

      • 2 votes
       - terill
       - 12:29 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      Even thought I do feel the father was selfish, in the end the mother did the right thing. This was about the child not his father.

      • 2 votes
       - T in VA
       - 12:30 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      I lost my dad when I was 3 weeks old. I would give anything to have the time Judah had with his dad. I think she made the right decision.

      • 3 votes
       - Nhadley
       - 12:31 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      This is two people who put the child first. Great mother, brave father, courageous kid.

      • 1 vote
       - 12:32 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
      Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

      A beautiful decision in a lousy situation. That boy learned a lot about how to live & forgive within a family. He's already passing it alon

         - Beezup
         - 12:33 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
        Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

        The most important thing in rasing children is to let them experience things that will help guide them to become their own person. Good/Ba

           - 12:34 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
          Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

          U did the right thing ! My ex moved my daughter 2 AZ & does not acknowledge WHAT a DAD might bring 2 the relationship.Its a LOT; I applaud

          • 1 vote
           - 12:36 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010
          Yes. She did the right thing. The risk was well worth the reward in this case.

          Yes, she did the right thing by allowing her son the benefit of getting to know his father. At least he'll have a memory to carry with him.

          • 1 vote
           - Suzer Q
           - 12:38 pm EST on Tue Jan 19, 2010

          Discussion with 239 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.

          Jump to discussion page: 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10

          Unfortuately, Judah's mom needs to discern "dad's" intentions, to protect Judah. I feelhis act is nefarious...and as a dad if I reject cleeving to my spouse and reject my fatherly duties to then ask to see my child, or children, just before I die without repenting from that selfish act I would not deserve to see the child, or children. For the child, or children, it would do more harm than good and I would know that. Judah's dad's last act before he dies is again a selfish act and in line with this man's true nature, it was always about him.

            Reply#121 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:01 PM EST

            Why do so many of you humans continue to pursue your sad ways of thinking? Life, this Earth and everything in it is for God’s children, God’s animals and God’s Earth. Not only was it good for this mother to have allowed her child’s father to have a chance to associate with his child, but it was also admirable of her. Unlike the hateful people who disagree with the mothers’ decision, the mother did realize that it was about the ‘child’. It was not about the sad thinking of the commenter’s here. When this child grows up, he will thank his mommy for the chance to have known his father. My father died when I was twelve years old. He was often sick and in the hospitals. I was blessed to have known him for the few years I did. It is a shame before God, that there are sick, sad people out there who would have denied this beautiful child the chance to have met and spend time with his father, his daddy.

            Victoria, you are a great person. God will have the same mercy on you, which you had for your child’s father. It was terrible what he did to you, but you are a really beautiful person to have put that aside and put your child and his father first. We definitely need more special people like you. God bless you

              Reply#122 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:02 PM EST

              --psycho, bitty, women-- What do you mean, "should I"? There was only ONE decision; for YOUR SON, not him. I am glad you are in therapy... Furthermore, you need to drop that friend. Filing for divorce is not intended to hurt you. Get over it, please, FOR YOU SON'S SAKE. Though, I am glad you put your son's needs above your own hurt feelings.

                Reply#123 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:06 PM EST

                Why give peace to the dying - it is the living who have to keep on living...I refused to go see my dying father because he was never there for me as a child or in my adult life. It has been 5 years and I DO NOT REGRET my decision at all.

                  Reply#124 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:06 PM EST

                  Why is this woman a saint for doing what she should have done? am I a saint for not speeding?

                  I am disgusted that it was even a dilemma.

                  People, man haters, have lost perspective.

                    Reply#125 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:12 PM EST

                    Good Decision!

                      Reply#126 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:27 PM EST

                      This story made me cry ...She did the right thing.Joshua had to know at least his dad loved him very much and he didn't leave him.

                      Of Course its also very painful when his dad walked away and left this lady alone while she is very vulnerable,7 months pregnant BUT think about the way he felt...he will die and never see his son again,could he handle 'em both? i mean,handling the death and the pain of not seeing his son ever again. Sometimes,when it's about "PAIN" Men are not as strong as Women.

                      She did a right decision to give the chance to him and to her son.

                      Even it was very tough for a little kid,surely he will be mature and stronger than many adults out there.

                      Good luck.

                        Reply#127 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:44 PM EST

                        ABSOLUTELY, He will probably not remember when he grows up, but at least he will know that he existed and maybe somewhere in his dreams, he will remember. and perhaps get to visit.  I took my ill daughter to see her father so he could at least see her once. She was a heart child. He may not have liked it at the time, but deep down, he was glad he got to see her. She is eternally 2.

                          Reply#128 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:47 PM EST

                          What a beautiful thing she gave to her son and his father.... the gift of love lives forever

                            Reply#129 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:52 PM EST

                            Regardless of the fact that the boy is young and she is the parent. The truth is that there is no question of "letting" the boy meet his dying father. She has no right to make the decision for the boy. The son must be allowed to meet his father, and therefore the mother is of course absolved of any responsibility.

                            Life is difficult sometimes, and there will always be grief because there will always be loss. That there are also happiness and gain is what allows us to be compassionate in our efforts to learn honorably the lessons placed before us, at any age...

                            My sympathies to the family, and the slow process of acceptance that the boy must come to terms with as he moves into adolescence and beyond. It appears he has a viable support network and room to grow, thus his prognosis bodes well.

                            Having lost my father at a very young age, absent any support system, I am well aware of the despair and consternation which can exude from a lack of understanding in the matter, and I am just lucky I was actually able to see him during his final moments.

                            Once again my condolences to the son...

                              Reply#130 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 7:56 PM EST

                              Yes, she did the right thing. Children need closure and they are always curious about their roots. I'm sure the father had to pray for forgiveness for abandoning his son that was given to him as a gift from heaven. When children grow up, they are always curious about their birth parents.

                                Reply#131 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 8:07 PM EST

                                Honestly, I do support the idea of the mother allowing her dying ex husband to meet their son because it's the appropriate thing to do althought their son is at a very young and tender age and may not fully comprehen the dilemma at least even if his dad is terminally ill it's a proper closure for his son and his mother. Aleast the son will have lasting memories of his father who he was and the time that they spent together he will have this experience to hold on to. Aleast, he met his dad at one time in his lifetime. His brief meeting with his dad will not be a mystery but something fulfilled despite the failed marriage between the son's mother and father. In closing the mother did the right thing by her son.

                                  Reply#132 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 8:13 PM EST

                                  Honestly, despite their failed marriage the mother made the right decesion to allow her son the meet his terminally ill father. Even though their son is at a very tender age aleast he will have this experience to hold on to. He will be able to remember the brief moment that he spent will his father. This is also a proper closure for the father since he's ill aleast he was able to see his son. The son's mother did right by her son.

                                    Reply#133 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 8:27 PM EST

                                    This dad did not abandon his son, the mother moved away with their son from Texas to New York-several thousand miles away. She took the son away from his father thus severing the contact for all intents and purposes. Since it is likely she spoke about this move for a while before it happened, the father really was set up to fail. It is shameful that no one but myself noticed this.

                                    That said, I applaud the mother for coming around and doing the right thing. Her son will never regret the time he had with his father.

                                      Reply#134 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 8:38 PM EST

                                      It is better to have loved and lost than to never have loved at all, what a touching story, she did the right thing, he will cherish anytime that he had with his dad, so sad of a story

                                        Reply#135 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 8:38 PM EST

                                        It was the right thing to do! Thanks mom!

                                          Reply#136 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 9:20 PM EST

                                          Absolutely did the right thing. I am 44 years old,I saw my father for the last time when I was 3,he died when I was 9. I still remember that,it doesnt fade.I wont tell you I was never confused or that I didnt hurt but I will tell you it helped make me who I am and I wouldnt take it back.I have NO doubt she did the right thing.

                                            Reply#137 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 9:21 PM EST

                                            It sounds like the dad rethought his former choices when he realized how ill he was. Better late than never. It's sad that little Judah probably won't have any memories of his dad by the time he grows up, but he will have pictures and stories about their time together. I'm sure he will be grateful for that. And compassion is very rarely the wrong choice.

                                              Reply#138 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 9:21 PM EST

                                              I lost both of my parents at a young age and, though I have my own memories of them, I would have been devastated if someone had denied me any time with them or a chance to know them and their love. Now that child will have pictures of his father holding him, stories of how they "rolled around together" and 'got along immediately'. And he will have what many children do not - the knowledge that his father (even though his father did not initially seek a relationship with him) wanted to know him and loved him. What a gift to be freed from wondering 'did this man ever love me?' - he will always know 'Yes he did!'. Bravo to mom - and peace, love, prayer & blessings to both she and her Judah.

                                                Reply#139 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 9:21 PM EST

                                                My vote was yes she did the right thing, but I also know she may possibly not know for many years if she did the right thing, only because today we do not know how this will effect her son until later in life. Today I have to commend what she did, it took alot for her to think of her son and not herself, I'm not sure all women could of did what she did.

                                                  Reply#140 - Tue Jan 19, 2010 9:29 PM EST
                                                  Jump to discussion page: 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10
                                                  Leave a Comment:
                                                  You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                  As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.