TODAY Moms

sponsored by
advertisement

Are kids spending too much time 'plugged in'?

According to a new report kids ages 8-18 are spending every waking moment – except for their time in school – using some electronic device. Some say we should accept this as part of children’s environment, while others fear for their health and well-being. What do you think?

advertisement
advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 24 short comments
Total of 1,556 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

51.3%
Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.
799 votes
12.5%
No. I agree that media is ubiquitous, so we should accept it and move on.
195 votes
36.1%
Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.
562 votes
Display Comments:
Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

I believe that their use of these devices can be managed with the help of the parents.

     - 12:25 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
    Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

    I have 7 children and they are only allowed to play games on weekends. I keep them occupied with books, board games, cooking,& family time

    • 1 vote
     - 1:49 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
    Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

    As a teenager myself, I would be devastaded if I couldn't be on the computer every now and then. But I'm not glued to it all the time.

       - 1:53 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
      Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

      Parents need to make sure that their kids keep their interpersonal and social skills honed which will better serve them in their adulthood.

         - 4:54 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
        Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

        Like anything else: moderation is the key.

           - 5:21 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
          Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

          I think the internet is ubiquitous, but highly disagree that we should just "move on." It's also not just children, but everyone these days

          • 1 vote
           - 7:11 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
          Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

          As a college student myself, I would say that 1) do useful things online, and 2) definitely you have to budget more than most are now.

          • 1 vote
           - 7:25 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
          Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

          I guess it's all non profit, but why don't these groups do studies on things that we DON'T have complete knowledge of ?

             - 9:59 pm EST on Wed Jan 20, 2010
            Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

            kids can't even talk in complete sentences now...it's all one word 'text' answers-they are losing the art of conversation andwriting skills

               - 9:22 am EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
              Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

              Writing skills have seriously declined. Use of "text language" has impacted spelling, sentence structure and clarity of thoughts in writing

                 - 10:06 am EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                If the family does a good job of socializing with their kids, they wouldn't be online quite often. For ex., taking the kids to the park to.

                   - 11:42 am EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                  Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

                  Yes the use of electronics should be limited, young people cannot even make change at a cash register.

                     - 12:29 pm EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                    No. I agree that media is ubiquitous, so we should accept it and move on.

                    I think its going to happen whether we like it or not, but we can still try to limit their useage.

                    • 1 vote
                     - 12:57 pm EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                    Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                    My kids grades go down when free time is on a gadget, and up when they are busy in a play or sport. No scientific study required.

                       - 1:07 pm EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                      Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                      My kids grades go down when free time is on a gadget, and up when they are busy in a play or sport. No scientific study required.

                         - 1:07 pm EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                        Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                        Instead of limiting use - just make sure there's some offline elements to their lives as well.

                           - drpaige
                           - 3:11 pm EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                          No. I agree that media is ubiquitous, so we should accept it and move on.

                          No

                          • 1 vote
                           - Surtr
                           - 5:34 pm EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                          No. I agree that media is ubiquitous, so we should accept it and move on.

                          It is up to parents to teach moderation, but technology will become absolutely ubiquitous within all areas of daily life within 2010-2020.

                             - Surtr
                             - 5:38 pm EST on Thu Jan 21, 2010
                            Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                            No one gives a crap about your kids but you, parents. Don't buy them the stuff if you don't want them to have it.

                               - 2:18 am EST on Fri Jan 22, 2010
                              Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                              Technology will only get better,,,everyone is plugged in! As long as you have more exercise than not being plugged in is okay...Like the WI

                                 - 10:52 am EST on Fri Jan 22, 2010
                                Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                                With the parents acting like parents and managing there kids time on the numerous devices kids will not live on them.

                                   - 4:58 pm EST on Fri Jan 22, 2010
                                  Maybe. I think it all depends on how we help our kids manage their activities and time. Keep them busy and they won’t have time to be online too much.

                                  screen time is a part of life... we should try to change what they do during it, not take it away... like something they will learn from

                                     - 12:09 pm EST on Sat Jan 23, 2010
                                    Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

                                    Seven and a half hours - per day - and it's even a question of whether they spend too much time online? Mmmm, brains.

                                       - 5:21 pm EST on Mon Jan 25, 2010
                                      Yes. Use of electronics should be limited before our kids turn into zombies.

                                      What I can't figure out is why parents are allowing this kind of zombie-like behavior. Parents, just say no! It really isn't that hard!

                                         - kfm6
                                         - 5:36 pm EST on Mon Jan 25, 2010

                                        Discussion with 11 comments - Click here to jump to the comment form.

                                        As a retired teacher and grandparent with 2 grandchildren, an iphone, kindle, email, and loving internet access...I don't understand parents giving their children all the electronics and then complaining that their children can't put it all down. Children see their parents facebooking, tweeting, texting meaningless juvenile garbage instead of having real relationships with real people. Where is it going? Children are what they see. Set guidelines, provide real life experiences, encourage, and electronics will fit into a schedule. They do not need to let electronics take total control because it is easier than parenting.

                                        • 2 votes
                                        Reply#1 - Wed Jan 20, 2010 7:56 PM EST

                                        Technology was initially developed to increase our leisure time, but it seems the exact opposite has happened. The more technology we have the more we depend on it and feel we have to use it.

                                        I think parents need to be ever vigilant with their children's use of technology. I think most if not all of the technology should be located outside children's bedrooms. How many kids do you know that have TVs, DVD players, video game consoles, stereos, computers, etc. all located in their bedrooms? It's no wonder kids are inundated with techie stuff!

                                        • 1 vote
                                        Reply#2 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 7:43 AM EST

                                        I don't see how this is possible - my son get's home from school at 4 p.m. Even if he went straight to the electronic media and didn't stop for dinner, going to the bathroom, or any other activity, that would have him on until 11:30 at night. Doesn't happen and the study seems flawed. I'll give you 3-4 hours max. Weekends might alter that "average" an hour or two, but that's when parenting comes in.

                                          Reply#3 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 8:49 AM EST

                                          I think it includes time before kids go to school, during school (use of their Ipods, cell phones) and after school. Most of my sons friends-age 11- bed time is around 10pm-yes you heard me correctly, 10pm. I'm in bed at 9:00!!! You are right when you say parenting needs to come in, however I am not seeing that happen in most families I know. Parents aren't raising children anymore, they are residing with a small roommate.

                                          • 1 vote
                                          #3.1 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 12:17 PM EST
                                          Reply

                                          We have a senior in high school and we caught her texting in class which is against school rules and our rules. So we emailed all her teachers (and cc'd her school counselor), told them what she was doing and canceled texting. Needless to say she was very upset! And her grades have come back up to her A's and B's. Several of her teachers emailed to thank us. We have no intention to re-activate the texting. Another plus is she wants to be more active in the family.

                                            Reply#4 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 9:16 AM EST

                                            Pam,

                                            I hope many more parents follow your advice before this generation winds up being lost.

                                              Reply#5 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 10:11 AM EST

                                              Yes, great job Pam! You did the responsible thing-even though it must have been hard to enforce. You were NOT selfish and stuck with the easy thing-you were thinking of only the benefit of your child. I applaude you for stepping up to the plate and being the parent. Hopefully more parents will learn from you.

                                                #5.1 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 12:10 PM EST
                                                Reply

                                                I hope this is a movement that infiltrates America sooner than later. I'm not against technology but I have my limit on how many devices I want my son to have, and I do not make it a priority when it comes to connecting, and engaging in healthy family time that seems to be lost in our society.

                                                Our children obesity/diabetes rate is at it's highest. We know that children are bombarded with technology, and exposing them to healthy content and in moderation is imperative to their little minds. But it seems like most parents don't even do that. Wake up parents! Our children today are rude, sassy, spoiled and act as if they are running the place-which most of them probably are in most house holds. If they are granted multiple electronics why shouldn't they expect to get what they request next month? I always told myself that when I had a family I would not allow the environment to be controlled by technology. When my 11 year old son isn't in sports he has 30 minutes total of media time (i.e, Wii, TV, Ipod games) a day, and 4 hours on the weekend. What is he doing the rest of the time? He is playing (connecting) with his friends and parents outdoors, playing board games, he learns to entertain himself-without technology-strengthening his creative/mechanical skills, listens to books on tape, the list goes on. He has manners, he respects his elders, he knows how to engage in conversations. While most of his friends sadly do not. He has PARENTS. If you're going to give your children electronic devices, curtail their exposure so the majority of the time your children spends awake, is with family, not with an electronic device. Engaging in healthy, fun activities with your children will give you all a rejuvenating feeling and will essentially remind you of the good ol' days.

                                                  Reply#6 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 11:53 AM EST

                                                  What is irritating about this study is that, first off the amount of online homework that is given out to these children elementary level. I have two children ages now, 21 and 23. Six years ago, the school was flabbergasted that I didn't have a computer in my home. They required it I was told. How were they supposed to do homework I was asked. With paper and a pencil and the brain and common sense God gave them I responded.

                                                  Children grade level ages K-9, shouldn't even have cell phones, and their internet use should be only given out for school work research. But wait, wasn't that what books were written for? Has that even become obsolete? This is why our children cannot read or write, and why we are bringing up children that feel entitled. Give it a rest PLEASE, we are raising an idiot society. Young people cannot even make simple change in a store unless the computer screen tells them how.

                                                    Reply#7 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 12:18 PM EST

                                                    When my kids are engaged in after school activities, no matter how many or how busy they get, their grades go up. When school vacation comes and they are on their DS all the time, they are aggitated and disconnected but its all they want to do. My kids totally understand this but they still want the gadgets. Its clear people surf the web and play online games to statisfy something missing in their lives....what would you rather see on a resume: "Active in community sports and activities" or "Got high score in Tetris and can text 50 words a minute" Lets help our kids make better choices. You dont give your kids potato chips and soda for dinner because its what they want, do you?

                                                      Reply#8 - Thu Jan 21, 2010 1:12 PM EST

                                                      I have a junior in high school who only has texting privleges with good grades. The grades go down and the texting goes away along with the phone/ipod. This has always been the rule so she clearly keeps her grades up. She has most of the current electronic devices and they all depend on her school grades and activities.

                                                        Reply#9 - Fri Jan 22, 2010 5:08 PM EST
                                                        Leave a Comment:
                                                        You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                        As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.